Content Creation in AI Era: Will AI Replace Content Creators?

7min.

Comments:1

21 October 2024

Content Creation in AI Era: Will AI Replace Content Creators?d-tags
The longer we use AI tools, the clearer it becomes that we still need human creativity, experience, and wit to produce content that both Google rewards with high ranks and users actually want to engage with. So, will AI replace content creators? Probably not anytime soon, and here’s why.

7min.

Comments:1

21 October 2024

Sure, AI can crank out written and visual content, but it often misses the emotional touch and recent information that make it truly unique and informative.

So, if you’re asking yourself: Will content creators be replaced by AI? than let’s first check the Google’s take on that issue.

Google and AI for Content Creation

Google isn’t a fan of repetitive, spammy, and low-quality content – something AI tools are infamous for producing. On their blog, you can read the following:

In 2022, we began tuning our ranking systems to reduce unhelpful, unoriginal content on Search and keep it at very low levels. We’re bringing what we learned from that work into the March 2024 core update.
[…]
We believe these updates will reduce the amount of low-quality content on Search and send more traffic to helpful and high-quality sites. Based on our evaluations, we expect that the combination of this update and our previous efforts will collectively reduce low-quality, unoriginal content in search results by 40%.

Google’s Blog; “New ways we’re tackling spammy, low-quality content on Search”

Why does it matter so much? As you can read in Why SEO Isn’t and Never Was Just for Bots if Google started surfacing low-quality, spammy content like what AI tools often generate, users would get fed up with reading the same uninspiring information conveyed with the same words and phrases, and eventually turn to other search engines.

So, will AI replace content creators? Not likely, because real value still comes from experienced human content creators.

That being said, you may be still wondering why so many business owners claim that are going to use AI for content creation.

ai in content creatorion stats

The answer is simple: If you can use the benefits offered by AI tools and combine them with human creativity and experience, you’ll be on the fast track to creating content that both meets Google’s needs and engages users. Here’s why.

AI in Content Creation and the Value of Good Human Content Creators

If the only goal is to write an article in record time, then some AI copywriting tools may help you do just that. However, if you strive to make your content really click with your target audience and rank on Google, you just need to bring a personal touch, and add creativity, emotions, and experience to content to your piece of content.

And AI simply can’t match that.

Yet. That’ why…

Marketers & Writers with Years of Experience Have a Big Advantage over AI Tools in Terms of Content Creation

Experienced writers and content creators aren’t just putting words together – they think about the big picture and confront it with what’s happening in the world at the moment of writing.

And this is even more true, but not limited to, journalists writing about issues related to science, health, and technology. Why?

Anyone who has written about science knows that something can be statistically significant and also relatively unimportant; context matters. But because the primary definition of the word “significant” in conversational language is “important” or “noteworthy,” this is a distinction that AI tools are unlikely to make. In other words, when drawing data from a journal article, an AI content generator may decide that something described as “significant” (in statistical terms) is “significant” (important), regardless of whether it is actually noteworthy.

Matt Shipman; “Why AI Writing Tools Are Useless for Science News”

But there is more to it.

While AI writing tools can pull information from many sources, it’s hard to know how reliable that information really is. There’s a lot of inaccurate content online, and some people intentionally mislead others.

Even trustworthy sources can change over time – new discoveries can show that what we thought we knew was wrong, and journal articles can be retracted due to mistakes or fraud.

So, will AI replace content creators? Again, not really simply because it’s still unclear how well AI can tell the difference between reliable and unreliable information.

A good human writer knows how to think critically and spot inaccurate claims or avoid citing retracted articles.

Unfortunately, we have no reason to believe that AI content generators are doing the same thing right now. In fact, we have every reason to be cautious about relying on AI tools in content creation.

Other Reasons Why AI Still Falls Flat in Content Creation

The ability to create content that reflects real values and culture is something that AI tools are still struggling with. And let’s face it, if you want your content to go viral or bring your target audience one step closer to convert, it must be relatable.  As wisely noted by our R&D and SEO Specialist:

When it comes to generating text, we can’t say that AI ‘knows’ or ‘understands’ anything. It’s really just playing the odds with word patterns based on its training data. Especially with new topics, it won’t have the info to write about them accurately.

Wojciech Urban
Wojciech Urban Senior SEO R&D Specialist

This insight shows the limitations of AI for content creation. Undoubtedly, it is great for spitting huge volumes of content, yet AI doesn’t really have that deeper understanding needed for new, complex, or sensitive subjects.

Human writers and content creators can take in new information and put it into cultural context – and this is one of the methods to make your content hit the right chord with your target audience. When you arouse a particular emotion in your prospects or followers for that matter, the more convinced they become to trust your brand. AI will not rather be able to do that anytime soon.

If you’re still not fully convinces, see more reasons…

Why Humans Are Still Ireplecable in Content Creation

Getting the most out of AI requires a solid plan and a framework that can hold it all together. You need some serious human expertise to make it work. Without that, AI tools can end up being almost useless.

#1: Expert Human Insight Is a Must

AI needs good input to do its thing, and that’s why human content creators are needed. We’re the ones who can check keywords or work with latent semantic indexing (LSI).

#2: Break Repetitive Patterns

If you have ever used AI tools for a couple of days, you probably noticed that the content they produce doesn’t vary much. To stand out from the crowd and make your writing or graphics interesting, it’s important to play around with sentence lengths, paragraph styles, and overall structure. Sure, some of this can be automated, but you still need a human touch to keep things on track.

#3: Give Your Audience What It Really Looks for

Let’s not forget that AI doesn’t really know what makes a piece of writing great, and it surely doesn’t know how to become a better writer who adapts their writing to changing consumer behavior and content consumption preferences.

#4: Want Rank? You Need Fresh Info

Platforms Google needs fresh pieces of information to, for example, keep their users satisfied or keep the knowledge graph trustworthy. AI tools can’t produce fresh content simply because latest information isn’t in their training data – these are the insights that only we humans can provide.

As you can see, professional human content creators know how to keep content accurate, appropriate, and high-quality. They know how to evoke emotions and think strategically. This way the content feels right and serves a purpose, meaning helps you achieve your business goals, which in most cases is selling more.

While talking about content that sells and evokes emotions…

Why Content Needs to Evoke Emotions (And Why AI Just Doesn’t Get It)

Content that makes you feel something is way more effective. Whether it’s a good laugh, a tear-jerking story, or a little spark of inspiration, emotions grab our attention and keep us hooked. And for that, you need to know how to create content that sells. When we feel connected – so when the piece of content we’re looking at resonates with us – we’re way more likely to share, comment, or even buy something.

Now, here’s where AI tools struggle. Even though using AI for content creation can save you some time, these tools are clueless when it comes to understanding human emotions.

AI-powered tools can’t grasp why we laugh, cry, or roll our eyes at certain things. So, the content they produce often ends up feeling flat and a bit… robotic.

So, will AI replace content creators? Not a chance! (At least for now.) AI can handle the grunt work, but it misses that special spark that makes writing engaging and memorable. Human content creators know how to tap into our feelings and create stories that resonate with us. They use their understanding of the human psyche, motivations, and drives to create messages that truly matter.

Content Is Way More than Just Text or Visuals, and That’s Another Reason Why You Shouldn’t Rely Solely on AI

Yep, that’s right. Publishing content isn’t enough. To truly reach your audience and make them fall in love with your brand, you need to give them choices in how, when, and where they consume your content. You need to have a solid content plan that includes thought-out publishing schedule. And that’s just one thing.

Another thing is that while AI for content creation can help you generate a new idea for another video or podcast, don’t expect it to help you maintain consistency across various multimedia formats. Why should you care? Because that’s absolutely fundamental for branding.

Again, this means that human supervision is still a must to tie it all together, making your brand truly unique to help it stand out from the crowd.

Are you now asking yourself…

Okay, But I’m Noticing a Growing Number of Jobs for AI Content Creators and AI Copywriters

You know what? The rise of jobs for AI content creators and copywriters is really about using AI as an assistant rather than a replacement. Businesses are feeling the pressure to produce content faster and more efficiently, and that’s where they use AI for content creation.

job offering ai content creator

an example of job description for AI content creator

These new roles focus on things like generating prompts – which were talked about in How to Use ChatGPT to Improve Writing – or reducing time devoted to research. It’s not about handing everything over to AI; it’s about using it to spark ideas and make the process smoother.

So, while some might wonder, “Will AI replace content creators?” – calm down. AI in content creation is – or at least should be – more about collaboration than competition.

job offering ai content creator 2

an example of a job description for AI Specialist for Graphics and Visual Content Creation

Summing Up: Will AI Replace Content Creators?

In a world where mediocre content is everywhere, the really unique and inspiring pieces of content will be the ones that help online businesses grow their customer base.

So what should you do?

That the advantage of both sides. Learn how to create amazing content and how to prompt AI to help you out. Creativity isn’t going anywhere, and as AI evolves, your talent and taste will only become more important.

To conclude, we leave you with this thought:

The real danger is not that computers will begin to think like men, but that men will begin to think like computers.

Sydney J. Harris American journalist
Author
Logo Delante
Author
Delante

Delante is an online marketing agency specialized in generating website traffic from search engines and paid ads (SEO / SEM). Over 80% of our clients are from rapidly growing e-commerce industry.